The individual confession service at a church had gotten on a roll. One many stood up and said, “I’ve been smoking three packs of cigarettes a day, and I’m going to quit.” Another man chimed in, “I’ve been getting drunk every weekend and I’m going to quit.” Yet another parishioner confessed, “I’ve been cursing a lot lately and I’m going to quit.” Caught in the exhilaration of the moment a little old lady stood up and said, “I haven’t been doing anything, and I’m going to quit.”
Hmm, there’s layers of meaning there if you think about it. This gets at a refrain that we find in Luke’s gospel and in its companion volume, Acts. The refrain is, “What then should we do?” The first time we find it is today as people respond to John the Baptist. John is preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. Repentance of course means a complete turn around from old and sinful practices. In response to John’s words the crowds ask him in verse 10, “What then should we do?” Tax collectors ask in verse 12 “What should we do?” Soldiers ask in verse 14, “What should we do?” And a lawyer in 20:25, a ruler in 18:18, a Jerusalem crowd in Acts 3:17, a jailer in Acts 16:30 and a zealous Jew in Acts 22:10 all ask, “What should we do?”
We’ve probably all asked ourselves that question at some point or another. What should we do? In Luke and Acts not only do a variety of people ask, “What should we do?” There is a variety of people who are asked that question. In Acts it is the apostles or Paul. In much of Luke it is Jesus. In our gospel reading it is John the Baptist. Their answers vary.
In our gospel reading the answers are pretty straightforward: share, be honest and fair, don’t lie, cheat, or steal, and don’t exploit others. Jesus himself gave more challenging answers. We aren’t going to look at his answers now. We will focus on John’s because when we look at them we think, “Sure, but that’s just being a decent person. Is that what God wants us to do, just be good people?”
That is a tempting answer. And many people take it. I don’t want to say it is a wrong or bad answer, but it misses the whole answer. What we should ask ourselves is, “Why? Why should I be a good person?” And that actually takes us to Jesus’ type of answers as well.
John’s message starts in an interesting way. He says, “You brood of vipers! Who warned you to flee from the wrath to come?” As I’m here close to Christmas with all the shopping and buying I tend to think, “John, you’re a bit of an odd-ball in the first place. I mean, the camel’s hair, eating bugs and honey, living in the wilderness. You’re not exactly a handsome stud in the public spotlight. These people have gone out of their way to see you, and all you can say is, ‘You brood of vipers!’ I think you’re in need of a marketing expert, not to mention an image consultant.”
John didn’t seem to be worried about popularity. He didn’t seem to worried about keeping his head attached to his shoulders either. But he did know a thing or two about how people think. He goes on to say, “Do not begin to say to yourselves, ‘We have Abraham as our ancestor’; for I tell you, God is able from these stones to raise up children to Abraham.”
That’s a bizarre statement if ever there was one. Here’s what John is getting at. Vipers were thought to eat their way out of their mother’s womb. It’s not a scientifically accurate thought, but it was a common thought in that day. John is saying the Jews have eaten their way out of a special covenant relationship with God. Why? How? Because John knows that the temptation for self-justification is universal.
I think you all know that if you think about something long and hard enough you can invent an excuse or justification for it; anything at all. Failed dieters know full well how many excuses and justifications they make. Almost anyone with an addiction does it all the time. And we can do it with our faith as well, offering God justifications for dismissing His call to us.
Here are some major categories of rationalizations that Christians give to God. The civil-religion rationalization claims that God needs us because we are a Christian nation. The pietistic rationalization offers individual piety as a substitute for genuine commitment, while limiting religion to matters of the heart and one’s private relationship with God. The universalist rationalization says that one’s response to God doesn’t really matter because ultimately all will be saved by God’s grace anyway. Whatever our modern equivalent to the appeal to Abraham, John’s call comes to us, “From these very stones…”
And so when we return to our original question, “What then shall we do?” We know that when we hear God’s answer the sinner in all of us is going to try to rationalize it away. But of course, don’t let that happen. Let the stronger part of yourself, the saint that God is at work in, respond, “Yes, Lord. I will do it.”
You see, the sinner in you is scared. It is small. It is always fearful. It is always full of needs. It’s worried about how it will work. It is worried about the safety of your image and ego. It is worried about being loved and accepted. It’s going to say to God, “Why should I do it? What’s in it for me?”
But the saint in you is big and powerful. The saint in you knows that all of the sinner’s worries have already been answered by God. It knows that God will provide for your basic needs. It knows that God will take care of your image and ego. And it knows that you are loved and accepted by God without merit. In other words, it is in tune to God’s grace. And it doesn’t have to ask “Why should I do it?” as a demand for justification. It already knows the answer: because it is God’s will. It is confident that God will provide.
Don’t ever let the scared little sinner in you bully around the big saint who is strong and confident and secure. When that happens it’s like a little cat chasing a big dog. It’s pretty silly. Sure, the two will conflict, like an angel on one shoulder and a devil on the other. But the angel’s voice is stronger. It is stronger because it is rooted in the inexhaustible supply of God’s gracious love.
It may seem like it is weakness to admit that you need God’s love and favor, and not be a totally self-made, and self-sustaining person, but it is actually strength. In knowing its need it connects to true strength. Having God’s favor, and knowing you have it without merit – in other words having God’s grace – is to be truly powerful.
Let me conclude with this little English table prayer:
Lord, give me grace to feel my need of grace; and give me grace to ask for grace; and give me grace to receive grace; and O Lord, when grace is given, give me grace to use it. Amen